Sooner Politics.org
  • Front Page
  • Oklahoma News
    • Oklahoma Reports
    • OCPAC
    • Oklahoma Constitution News
    • Oklahoma Center Square
    • AP Wire
    • NewsBreak Oklahoma
    • Oklahoma Almanac
    • Trump's America
    • Muskogee Now
    • Capitol Beat
    • Faked Out Sports
    • OSU Sports
  • SoonerPolitics TV
    • Me, Myself, & Liberty
    • AircraftSparky
    • E PLURIBUS OTAP
    • Tapp's Common Sense
    • Red River TV
  • Legislative Watch
    • Legislative Scores
    • Right To Arms
    • Okla. Medical Marijuana Law
    • Congressional Tweets
    • Kevin Stitt
    • Lawmaker's Journal
  • Editorial
    • From the Editor
    • Weekend Report
    • 3D Politics
    • Reagan Speaks
    • On This Date
  • Sooner Issues
    • Corruption Chronicle
    • Constitutional Grounds
    • State Groups
  • Sooner Analysts
    • OCPA
    • Ekklesia of Oklahoma
    • Pat Campbell
    • Muskogee Politico
    • 1889 Institute
    • Steve Byas
    • Everett Piper
    • Michael Bates
    • Steve Fair
    • Andrew Spiropoulos
    • Rooke Report
    • Josh Lewis
    • Sooner Tea Party
    • Nigel O'mally
    • Cut The Crap
    • KOKC
  • Nation
    • Breitbart News
    • Rush Limbaugh
    • Daily wire
    • Steven Crowder
    • InfoWars News
    • The F1rst
    • NewsMax
    • America's Voice
    • Ron Paul Institute
    • Bill Gertz
    • D i s r n
    • Just the News
    • Trey Gowdy
    • Fox Politics
    • National Commentary
  • Wit & Whimsy
    • Terrence Williams
    • Witty Cartoons
    • Will Rogers Said
    • Repository of Pith
    • Dubiosity
    • Steeple Chasers
    • The Partisan
    • Satire
    • New Media Guide
  • SoonerPolitics.org
    • Masthead

Plumber Licensing: Another Monopoly That Fails the Smell Test

1/18/2021

Comments

 
by Tyler Williamson
Wed, 06 Jan 2021

​Why must aspiring plumber contractors’ complete multiple years of education, multiple years of lower level work, and pay a hefty annual fee just to obtain a license? What justification does the state provide for these requirements? According to the Construction Industries Board (CIB), which oversees plumber contractor licensing, these requirements are in place to “protect life and property,” to “provide a fair and healthy market environment for the contractor business,” and to show Oklahomans that plumber contractors meet a “minimum standard of competency.” My recent addition to the 1889 Institute’s Occupational Licensing Directory discusses the 1955 Plumber License Law and the licensing regime that developed pursuant to it, finds it totally unnecessary, and recommends a simple solution.

Picture

  First, the services plumber contractors provide on a daily basis pose no real danger to life or property. Think about it: fixing sinks, faucets, toilets, sewer lines, etc. is relatively straightforward stuff. In addition, for large jobs or those that require more skill or expertise, inspection and permitting requirements of both the state and municipalities mitigate most of the risk. The real danger lies in a cloistered group of plumbers setting unreasonably high prices because they face limited competition, but I digress.

Second, the idea that the state needs to interfere in a market in order for it to be fair and healthy is laughable (nothing says “fair and healthy market” quite like getting fined $200 for offering to unclog someone’s toilet while unlicensed). Market distortion caused by state interference has artificially reduced the supply of contractors in a time when demand is high. In fact, such anti-competitive market interference (via licensing schemes) may actually be in violation of federal antitrust laws. Even if these licensing schemes are not in violation, it is because states’ rights have carried the day, not because the licensing boards are justified and do anything but limit competition.

Finally, obtaining information on the quality or competency of plumber contractors is relatively easy. You can search any number of plumbers on the internet and find plenty of helpful information from Yelp, Consumer Reports, Google Reviews, social media, or sights like Angie’s List. With such a plethora of information available, one would think that the need for the state to certify some arbitrarily determined “minimum standard of competency,” would be totally unnecessary, yet the law still exists. Indeed, Great Britain (which is no stranger to licensing) does not even have state mandated licensing requirements for plumbers, but instead relies on a system of private certification.

Private certification could be a more meaningful shorthand indicator of quality and also allow for greater transparency in occupations than traditional licensing. The 1889 Institute has previously discussed private certification as an alternative to occupational licensing in A Win-Win for Consumers and Professionals Alike: An Alternative to Occupational Licensing. This system of private certification would maintain a high standard of quality and competency, while also removing the market distortion caused by the monopolistic licensing regimes that are currently in place.

What’s not to like about that? Sounds like a win-win to me.

Tyler Williamson is a Research Associate at 1889 Institute and can be reached at twilliamson@1889institute.org.
Comments
    Picture

    The 1889 Institute:  

    Byron Schlomach, Ben Lepak & the team of public policy researchers.

    Archives

    April 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020

    Categories

    All

    RSS Feed

​FRONT PAGE •  OKLAHOMA NEWS • EDITORIAL • SOONER ISSUES •​ STATE GROUPS •​ SOONER ANALYSTS •​ LAWMAKER'S JOURNAL •​ NATION •​ NATIONAL COMMENTARY •​ CARTOONS •​ ​
Picture

918 . 928 . 7776

 SoonerPolitics.org is committed to informing & mobilizing conservative Oklahomans for civic reform & restored liberty. We seeks to utilize the efforts of all cooperative facets of the Conservative movement... Content of the diverse columns are solely at the discretion of the dozens of websites who create the content.   David Van Risseghem  is the founder of this platform.
 Sooner Politics News is a platform, not a media site. All our bloggers get their feeds promoted regardless of content. As soon as We suppress or delete even one posting, we become an endorser of whatever We didn't censor..The publisher doesn't (and could not) logically agree with all the content, so we would not expect any rational reader to agree, either. What we do hope, is that readers will think for themselves, and at least be better informed of the issues, events, and values that our citizen journalists work hard to provide for free.. We automate much of the tasks so that our sources' content gets as much exposure as possible. We encourage constructive discussion & debate. The solution is more free speech, not less.​

  • Front Page
  • Oklahoma News
    • Oklahoma Reports
    • OCPAC
    • Oklahoma Constitution News
    • Oklahoma Center Square
    • AP Wire
    • NewsBreak Oklahoma
    • Oklahoma Almanac
    • Trump's America
    • Muskogee Now
    • Capitol Beat
    • Faked Out Sports
    • OSU Sports
  • SoonerPolitics TV
    • Me, Myself, & Liberty
    • AircraftSparky
    • E PLURIBUS OTAP
    • Tapp's Common Sense
    • Red River TV
  • Legislative Watch
    • Legislative Scores
    • Right To Arms
    • Okla. Medical Marijuana Law
    • Congressional Tweets
    • Kevin Stitt
    • Lawmaker's Journal
  • Editorial
    • From the Editor
    • Weekend Report
    • 3D Politics
    • Reagan Speaks
    • On This Date
  • Sooner Issues
    • Corruption Chronicle
    • Constitutional Grounds
    • State Groups
  • Sooner Analysts
    • OCPA
    • Ekklesia of Oklahoma
    • Pat Campbell
    • Muskogee Politico
    • 1889 Institute
    • Steve Byas
    • Everett Piper
    • Michael Bates
    • Steve Fair
    • Andrew Spiropoulos
    • Rooke Report
    • Josh Lewis
    • Sooner Tea Party
    • Nigel O'mally
    • Cut The Crap
    • KOKC
  • Nation
    • Breitbart News
    • Rush Limbaugh
    • Daily wire
    • Steven Crowder
    • InfoWars News
    • The F1rst
    • NewsMax
    • America's Voice
    • Ron Paul Institute
    • Bill Gertz
    • D i s r n
    • Just the News
    • Trey Gowdy
    • Fox Politics
    • National Commentary
  • Wit & Whimsy
    • Terrence Williams
    • Witty Cartoons
    • Will Rogers Said
    • Repository of Pith
    • Dubiosity
    • Steeple Chasers
    • The Partisan
    • Satire
    • New Media Guide
  • SoonerPolitics.org
    • Masthead