Sooner Politics.org
  • Front Page
  • Oklahoma News
    • OKCtalk
    • OCPAC
    • Oklahoma Constitution News
    • Oklahoma History
    • Today, In History
    • Oklahoma Center Square
    • Faked Out Sports
    • AP Wire
    • NewsBreak Oklahoma
    • Inside the Capitol
    • Lawton Rocks
    • Muskogee Now
    • OSU Sports
  • Podcasts
  • SPTV
    • Fresh Black Coffee, with Eddie Huff
    • AircraftSparky
    • Red River TV
    • Oklahoma TV
    • E PLURIBUS OTAP
    • Tapp's Common Sense
  • Editorial
    • From the Editor
    • Weekend Report
  • Sooner Issues
    • Corruption Chronicle
    • Constitutional Grounds
    • State Groups
  • Sooner Analysts
    • OCPA
    • Muskogee Politico
    • Patrick McGuigan
    • SoonerPoll
    • Everett Piper
    • Andrew Spiropoulos
    • Tulsa Devil's Advocate
    • Eddie Huff & Friends
    • 1889 Institute
    • Steve Byas
    • Michael Bates
    • Steve Fair
    • Josh Lewis
    • Tulsa Today
    • OK2A
    • Dr. Jim Meehan
    • AFP Oklahoma
    • Sooner Tea Party
  • Nation
    • Bongino Report
    • Breitbart News
    • Daily wire
    • Steven Crowder
    • InfoWars News
    • Jeff Davis
    • Alex Lains
    • The F1rst
    • Nigel Farage
    • NewsMax
    • America's Voice
    • Ron Paul Institute
    • Bill Gertz
    • Emerald
    • Rooke Report
    • Just the News
    • Trey Gowdy
    • Fox Politics
    • National Commentary
  • Wit & Whimsy
    • Libs of Tiktok
    • It's Still The Law
    • Terrence Williams
    • Witty Cartoons
    • Will Rogers Said
    • Steeple Chasers
    • The Partisan
    • Satire
  • SoonerPolitics.org

AG Hunter Claims 2-Year Residency Waiting Periods 'Unenforceable'

2/3/2020

Comments

 

He went on to say that residency, itself is likely unconstitutional in commerce law.

  In a separate but similar application of commerce law, the Oklahoma Attorney General, Mike Hunter; told the State Liquor Agency, ABLE Commission; that the statutes requiring Liquor businesses to be owned by people with a 5 year residency requirement; is likely afoul of  federal interstate commerce dictates.
  Could  Oklahoma Marijuana laws be struck down, as well?
  ABLE had sought the AG's opinion in light of a recent federal ruling on a Tennessee law to restrict out-of-state wineries. He concluded;
​  "Your question is what effect, if any, the Tennessee Wine decision has on the validity of the residency requirements found in Section 4 of Article 28A of our State Constitution. We believe the U.S. Supreme Court would now hold those requirements to be unconstitutional."
  Another potential matter is the ban on out-of-state products being banned, while in-state versions are legal. This  would possibly open Oklahoma to cannabis products from Colorado. It certainly opens Oklahoma to trace hemp products.
  Protectionism is the term that Hunter finally alleges. He says the courts would ultimately accuse the legislature of being motivated in a way that the US Constitution does not allow.  At the ratification of the 1789 US Constitution, the states entered into an open trade agreement. Our constitution cannot tolerate this. It's one thing to ban a product from another state if you're also banning the local versions of the product or service. But a ban on Texas beef, for instance; would clearly be a violation designed to bolster Oklahoma Beef.
Picture
Oklahoma Attorney General, Michael Hunter

"In 2005. for example. the U.S. Supreme Court held that state
statutes that 'allow in-state wineries to sell wine directly to consumers in that State but prohibit
out-of-state wineries from doing so' violate the dormant Commerce Clause.  The Court found it 'evident that the object and design' of the statutes was 'to grant in-state
wineries a competitive advantage over wineries located beyond the States’ borders,' and held that
such 'discrimination is neither authorized nor permitted by the Twenty-first Amendment.' " 
  In the next section of Hunter's letter, he clearly warns ABLE that the legislature violated federal law, with clear unconstitutional intent.
  "On June 26, 2019, the U.S. Supreme Court struck down Tennessee’s two-year 'durational residency' requirement as unconstitutional. Tennessee Wine, 139 S.Ct. 2449. As in Granhoim, the Tennessee statute was not saved by the Twenty-first Amendment. which 'cannot be given an interpretation that overrides all previously adopted constitutional provisions.'  Indeed, the Court noted, it had already held in the past that alcohol regulations must comply with the free Speech. Establishment. Equal Protection. and Due Process Clauses. among others. so the Commerce Clause would be no different. The aim of the Twenty-first Amendment, the Court insisted, 'was not to give States a free hand to restrict the importation of alcohol for purely protectionist purposes.' Id. And the 'predominant effect' of Tennessee’s durational residency requirement, the Court held, was protectionism"
  "First, the Court emphasized that, pursuant to the dormant Commerce Clause. “if a state law discriminates against. . . nonresident economic actors, the law can be sustained only on a showing that it is narrowly tailored to advance a legitimate local purpose.”
 "The Supreme Court has not simply rejected the durational residency requirement, but residency as a prerequisite altogether. In other words, by employing such expansive language the Supreme Court signaled its unwillingness to uphold any residency requirement in this particular context."
  "The Court’s logic extends to non-durational residency requirements and those outside the retail context. The Court, for instance, held that 'because Tennessee’s 2-year residency requirement for retail license applicants blatantly favors the State’s residents and has little relationship to public health and safety, it is unconstitutional.' "
  " ​To summarize, in Tennessee Wine the U.S. Supreme Court stated it will apply intense scrutiny to state residency requirements in the context of alcohol regulation, it used expansive language and logic that strongly suggests its reasoning will apply to durational and non-durational residency requirements and to retailer and wholesaler licenses, it dismissed virtually all arguments that could be made in favor of residency requirements. and it made clear that its decision should not be interpreted narrowly."
Comments
    Picture

    Nigel O'Mally

    Nigel heavily focuses on the medical research and drug policy topics at SoonerPolitics, from an international perspective &  a background in homeopathic herbs and agrarian culture.

    Archives

    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018

    Categories

    All

    RSS Feed

​FRONT PAGE •  OKLAHOMA NEWS • EDITORIAL • SOONER ISSUES •​ STATE GROUPS •​ SOONER ANALYSTS •​ LAWMAKER'S JOURNAL •​ NATION •​ NATIONAL COMMENTARY •​ CARTOONS •​ ​
Picture

918 . 928 . 7776

 SoonerPolitics.org is committed to informing & mobilizing conservative Oklahomans for civic reform & restored liberty. We seeks to utilize the efforts of all cooperative facets of the Conservative movement... Content of the diverse columns are solely at the discretion of the dozens of websites who create the content.   David Van Risseghem  is the founder of this platform.
 Sooner Politics News is a platform, not a media site. All our bloggers get their feeds promoted regardless of content. As soon as We suppress or delete even one posting, we become an endorser of whatever We didn't censor..The publisher doesn't (and could not) logically agree with all the content, so we would not expect any rational reader to agree, either. What we do hope, is that readers will think for themselves, and at least be better informed of the issues, events, and values that our citizen journalists work hard to provide for free.. We automate much of the tasks so that our sources' content gets as much exposure as possible. We encourage constructive discussion & debate. The solution is more free speech, not less.​

  • Front Page
  • Oklahoma News
    • OKCtalk
    • OCPAC
    • Oklahoma Constitution News
    • Oklahoma History
    • Today, In History
    • Oklahoma Center Square
    • Faked Out Sports
    • AP Wire
    • NewsBreak Oklahoma
    • Inside the Capitol
    • Lawton Rocks
    • Muskogee Now
    • OSU Sports
  • Podcasts
  • SPTV
    • Fresh Black Coffee, with Eddie Huff
    • AircraftSparky
    • Red River TV
    • Oklahoma TV
    • E PLURIBUS OTAP
    • Tapp's Common Sense
  • Editorial
    • From the Editor
    • Weekend Report
  • Sooner Issues
    • Corruption Chronicle
    • Constitutional Grounds
    • State Groups
  • Sooner Analysts
    • OCPA
    • Muskogee Politico
    • Patrick McGuigan
    • SoonerPoll
    • Everett Piper
    • Andrew Spiropoulos
    • Tulsa Devil's Advocate
    • Eddie Huff & Friends
    • 1889 Institute
    • Steve Byas
    • Michael Bates
    • Steve Fair
    • Josh Lewis
    • Tulsa Today
    • OK2A
    • Dr. Jim Meehan
    • AFP Oklahoma
    • Sooner Tea Party
  • Nation
    • Bongino Report
    • Breitbart News
    • Daily wire
    • Steven Crowder
    • InfoWars News
    • Jeff Davis
    • Alex Lains
    • The F1rst
    • Nigel Farage
    • NewsMax
    • America's Voice
    • Ron Paul Institute
    • Bill Gertz
    • Emerald
    • Rooke Report
    • Just the News
    • Trey Gowdy
    • Fox Politics
    • National Commentary
  • Wit & Whimsy
    • Libs of Tiktok
    • It's Still The Law
    • Terrence Williams
    • Witty Cartoons
    • Will Rogers Said
    • Steeple Chasers
    • The Partisan
    • Satire
  • SoonerPolitics.org