Sooner Politics.org
  • Front Page
  • Oklahoma News
    • Oklahoma Reports
    • OCPAC
    • Oklahoma Constitution News
    • Citizen of the Year
    • Oklahoma History
    • Today, In History
    • Oklahoma Center Square
    • Faked Out Sports
    • AP Wire
    • NewsBreak Oklahoma
    • Inside the Capitol
    • Lawton Rocks
    • Muskogee Now
    • OSU Sports
  • Podcasts
  • SPTV
    • Fresh Black Coffee, with Eddie Huff
    • AircraftSparky
    • Red River TV
    • Oklahoma TV
    • E PLURIBUS OTAP
    • Tapp's Common Sense
  • Editorial
    • From the Editor
    • Weekend Report
    • 3D Politics
    • Reagan Speaks
  • Sooner Issues
    • Corruption Chronicle
    • Constitutional Grounds
    • State Groups
  • Sooner Analysts
    • OCPA
    • Muskogee Politico
    • Rooke Report
    • SoonerPoll
    • Everett Piper
    • Andrew Spiropoulos
    • Tulsa Devil's Advocate
    • Eddie Huff & Friends
    • 1889 Institute
    • Steve Byas
    • Michael Bates
    • Steve Fair
    • Josh Lewis
    • Tulsa Today
    • OK2A
    • Dr. Jim Meehan
    • AFP Oklahoma
    • Sooner Tea Party
  • Nation
    • Bongino Report
    • Breitbart News
    • Daily wire
    • Steven Crowder
    • InfoWars News
    • Jeff Davis
    • Alex Lains
    • The F1rst
    • Nigel Farage
    • NewsMax
    • America's Voice
    • Ron Paul Institute
    • Bill Gertz
    • Emerald
    • Just the News
    • Trey Gowdy
    • Fox Politics
    • National Commentary
  • Wit & Whimsy
    • Libs of Tiktok
    • It's Still The Law
    • Terrence Williams
    • Witty Cartoons
    • Will Rogers Said
    • Steeple Chasers
    • The Partisan
    • Satire
  • SoonerPolitics.org

Why Did Gov. Stitt Declare 'A State Of Riot'?

4/2/2020

Comments

 
OKC Attorney, Frank Urbanic; penned this article at his own law firm's website. We asked to reprint it for our readers.

IS GOVERNOR STITT’S CORONAVIRUS EMERGENCY ORDER LEGAL?

POSTED BY FRANK URBANIC ON APRIL 2, 2020
  On March 15, 2020, Oklahoma Governor Kevin Stitt issued his first Coronavirus executive order. He declared that there was “an emergency caused by the impending threat of COVID-19 to the people of this State and the public’s peace, health, and safety.” He activated the State Emergency Operation Plan. The only authority he cited in his declaration was Article VI Section 2 of the Oklahoma Constitution.
  On March 24, Governor Stitt issued his Fourth Amended Executive Order. Among many other things, he banned gatherings of more than ten people. He also ordered that businesses not deemed “essential” to close.
  Based on my research, I believe these executive orders are invalid. Succinctly, the governor is trying to shoehorn this situation into Oklahoma’s Riot Control and Prevention Act. There was neither a riot nor impending riot that required the use of this Riot Act.
  Where does the governor’s authority to do this come from?  After asking people and the media for weeks where this power comes from and not getting an answer, I finally decided to do the research myself. It was not easy to find.​
Picture
This law states, “The Governor, after finding that a public disorder, disaster or riot exists within this state or any part thereof which affects life, health, property or the public peace, may proclaim a state of emergency in the area affected.”

  My initial research took me to 63 O.S. § 1-504, the law covering quarantine in our Public Health Code. It talks about what a local health officer can do when he or she determines or suspects that someone has a communicable disease of public health concern. This is what most other sites believe gives the governor his powers during this pandemic. Not correct.
I thought that maybe the Attorney General’s clarification on the governor’s executive order would be helpful since he said that a violation of the executive order is a misdemeanor. There was no citation in the AG’s memo to any law. Maybe he was referring to 21 O.S. § 1195, Penalty for Violating Quarantine Laws or Orders? Nope, since that refers to orders by a “health officer”–not the governor.
Riot Control and Prevention ActI finally found it on OKC’s post on their “shelter in place” order. The governor is using 21 O.S. §§ 1321.1-1321.11, the RIOT CONTROL AND PREVENTION ACT, to justify his executive order.
This law states, “The Governor, after finding that a public disorder, disaster or riot exists within this state or any part thereof which affects life, health, property or the public peace, may proclaim a state of emergency in the area affected.”
So in order for this act to be invoked, there must be either a public disorder, disaster, or riot. The clear intent of this law is that it be invoked when there’s either rioting/civil unrest in the streets or the danger of immediate rioting or civil unrest, due to some sort of “disaster.” There’s obviously no riot or public disorder. So is he saying there’s currently a “disaster”? Requiring the issuance of an executive order closing businesses and preventing more than 10 people from gathering in one location? Apparently he does. I don’t. I think this is an abuse of this statute. It clearly wasn’t intended for use with “health emergencies.”
Catastrophic Health Emergency Powers ActProof that the Riot Control and Prevention Act wasn’t meant for health emergencies is the fact that we already have a Catastrophic Health Emergency Powers Act, which is specifically for health emergencies–obviously. A “catastrophic health emergency” is defined as an occurrence of imminent threat of an illness or health condition that:
  1. is believed to be caused by any of the following:
    1. a nuclear attack,
    2. bioterrorism,
    3. a chemical attack, or
    4. the appearance of a novel or previously controlled or eradicated infectious agent or biological toxin, and
  2. poses a high probability of any of the following harms:
    1. a large number of deaths in the affected population,
    2. a large number of serious or long-term disabilities in the affected population, or
    3. widespread exposure to an infectious or toxic agent that poses a significant risk of substantial future harm to a large number of people in the affected population.
Why didn’t Governor Stitt declare a catastrophic health emergency under the Catastrophic Health Emergency Powers Act? Perhaps it’s because the Riot Act gives the governor more powers? There’s no criminal penalty associated with the violation of the Health Act. With the Riot Act, there are two provisions that allow for criminal penalties. So when it comes to controlling peoples’ behavior, the Health Act has no teeth–the Riot Act does.
Can I get charged with a crime for not following the executive order?According to our AG, violating the executive orders is a misdemeanor. So, yes, you can be arrested and charged with violating the executive orders. But, is the executive order lawful? I don’t think so. It’s fundamentally flawed because it’s using a law that wasn’t intended for this purpose. They’re stretching the limits of the Riot Act to fit their goals.
Is this really a “disaster”? I believe the statute intended this to be used for natural disasters–such as tornadoes. When a tornado hits a town, it could decimate utilities and law enforcement’s ability to do its job. The governor would typically declare it a “disaster area” for obvious reasons. Is all of Oklahoma now a “disaster area” because some people are infected with a virus? I don’t think so.
Disaster is defined as “a sudden event, such as an accident or a natural catastrophe, that causes great damage or loss of life.” It sets a terrible precedent to declare something a “disaster” when there’s not an event that actually constitutes a real disaster.
How are cities able to threaten business and people who don’t comply?Cities do this because they have their own municipal code that’s authorized under the Riot Act. Oklahoma City’s municipal code says that, “The Mayor, after finding that a public disorder, disaster or riot exists which affects life, health, property or the public peace, may proclaim a state of emergency in the area affected.” It references riots and things that go on during riots in adjacent sections of the code. So, again, this code was clearly written to deal with RIOTS or the threat of RIOTS–not viruses. The penalty for violating this law is up to six months in jail and a $750 fine. Since I believe these municipalities are declaring emergencies based on an illegitimate application of the Riot Act, the municipalities’ orders are also invalid.
What are your thoughts? Do you agree? Disagree?Please let me know if I posted something inaccurate so I can correct it.
 Former Oklahoma Senator, Don Rubottom, reviewed the attorney's assessment. Rubottom has been an officer of the Florida legislator much of the past 25 years. Here's what he had to say;
Picture
  "Great analysis. This is consistent with my analysis of Florida emergency laws. The locals are relying on an emergency law that does not allow curfews. In Florida, only the state health officer appears to have quarantine powers. I know Governor DeSantis has directed the state health officer to issue certain orders, not sure about what law he relies on for his own "safer at home" order.
  It appears to me that few or none of the governors, mayors and local councils have bothered even seeking legal clarity but are issuing orders to quiet the media mob or other chicken littles. I believe we need some quarantines in place, better rolling with the epidemic than hitting everyone everywhere the same. But they should be issued according to law, not arbitrary capricious utterances of locals with no health authority."

Picture
Read the rest of Frank Urbanic's articles, at his law firm website.

    Comments

      Sooner Politics
        Editorial  

      Picture
      David Van Risseghem reports the events and adds some perspective. 


      Search Our Archives.

      Get A Daily News Email

      * indicates required

      Get new posts by email:


      Archives

      August 2022
      July 2022
      June 2022
      May 2022
      April 2022
      March 2022
      February 2022
      January 2022
      December 2021
      November 2021
      October 2021
      September 2021
      August 2021
      July 2021
      June 2021
      May 2021
      April 2021
      March 2021
      February 2021
      January 2021
      December 2020
      November 2020
      October 2020
      September 2020
      August 2020
      July 2020
      June 2020
      May 2020
      April 2020
      March 2020
      February 2020
      January 2020
      December 2019
      November 2019
      October 2019
      September 2019
      August 2019
      July 2019
      June 2019
      May 2019
      April 2019
      March 2019
      February 2019
      January 2019
      December 2018
      November 2018
      October 2018
      September 2018
      August 2018
      July 2018
      June 2018
      May 2018
      April 2018
      March 2018
      February 2018
      January 2018
      December 2017
      November 2017
      October 2017
      September 2017
      August 2017
      July 2017
      June 2017
      May 2017
      April 2017
      March 2017
      February 2017
      January 2017
      December 2016
      November 2016
      October 2016
      September 2016
      August 2016
      July 2016
      June 2016
      May 2016
      April 2016
      August 2015
      January 2015


      Subscribe in a reader
      ​We recently moved our blog. Our archives are still partially stored at our old site. 

      Author

      David Van Risseghem  is the Publisher of SoonerPolitics.org. The resource is committed to informing & mobilizing conservative Oklahomans for civic reform.  This endeavor seeks to utilize the efforts of all cooperative facets of the Conservative movement...

      ​"No politician 'checks off every box" in your list of issues. You have to prioritize and use personal discretion regarding every current and future issue that you can imagine. Then you have to also judge integrity & consistency. A candidate's openness to study the issues & courage to think for themselves. Then you need to review their honesty & work ethic.  I respect any voter's decision, when they've informed themselves and took voting seriously." - David Van Risseghem
    ​FRONT PAGE •  OKLAHOMA NEWS • EDITORIAL • SOONER ISSUES •​ STATE GROUPS •​ SOONER ANALYSTS •​ LAWMAKER'S JOURNAL •​ NATION •​ NATIONAL COMMENTARY •​ CARTOONS •​ ​
    Picture

    918 . 928 . 7776

     SoonerPolitics.org is committed to informing & mobilizing conservative Oklahomans for civic reform & restored liberty. We seeks to utilize the efforts of all cooperative facets of the Conservative movement... Content of the diverse columns are solely at the discretion of the dozens of websites who create the content.   David Van Risseghem  is the founder of this platform.
     Sooner Politics News is a platform, not a media site. All our bloggers get their feeds promoted regardless of content. As soon as We suppress or delete even one posting, we become an endorser of whatever We didn't censor..The publisher doesn't (and could not) logically agree with all the content, so we would not expect any rational reader to agree, either. What we do hope, is that readers will think for themselves, and at least be better informed of the issues, events, and values that our citizen journalists work hard to provide for free.. We automate much of the tasks so that our sources' content gets as much exposure as possible. We encourage constructive discussion & debate. The solution is more free speech, not less.​

    • Front Page
    • Oklahoma News
      • Oklahoma Reports
      • OCPAC
      • Oklahoma Constitution News
      • Citizen of the Year
      • Oklahoma History
      • Today, In History
      • Oklahoma Center Square
      • Faked Out Sports
      • AP Wire
      • NewsBreak Oklahoma
      • Inside the Capitol
      • Lawton Rocks
      • Muskogee Now
      • OSU Sports
    • Podcasts
    • SPTV
      • Fresh Black Coffee, with Eddie Huff
      • AircraftSparky
      • Red River TV
      • Oklahoma TV
      • E PLURIBUS OTAP
      • Tapp's Common Sense
    • Editorial
      • From the Editor
      • Weekend Report
      • 3D Politics
      • Reagan Speaks
    • Sooner Issues
      • Corruption Chronicle
      • Constitutional Grounds
      • State Groups
    • Sooner Analysts
      • OCPA
      • Muskogee Politico
      • Rooke Report
      • SoonerPoll
      • Everett Piper
      • Andrew Spiropoulos
      • Tulsa Devil's Advocate
      • Eddie Huff & Friends
      • 1889 Institute
      • Steve Byas
      • Michael Bates
      • Steve Fair
      • Josh Lewis
      • Tulsa Today
      • OK2A
      • Dr. Jim Meehan
      • AFP Oklahoma
      • Sooner Tea Party
    • Nation
      • Bongino Report
      • Breitbart News
      • Daily wire
      • Steven Crowder
      • InfoWars News
      • Jeff Davis
      • Alex Lains
      • The F1rst
      • Nigel Farage
      • NewsMax
      • America's Voice
      • Ron Paul Institute
      • Bill Gertz
      • Emerald
      • Just the News
      • Trey Gowdy
      • Fox Politics
      • National Commentary
    • Wit & Whimsy
      • Libs of Tiktok
      • It's Still The Law
      • Terrence Williams
      • Witty Cartoons
      • Will Rogers Said
      • Steeple Chasers
      • The Partisan
      • Satire
    • SoonerPolitics.org